Is a bread maker better than an oven? Bread machine’s advantages and disadvantages

Is a bread maker better than an oven? Bread machine's advantages and disadvantages

Is a bread maker better than an oven? Bread machine’s advantages and disadvantages

For the novice baker, making delicious homemade bread can be a daunting task. With so many different methods and techniques out there, it’s hard to know which one will give you the best results. Which begs the question: Is a bread maker better than an oven?

In this blog post from Fabrice Refay, we’ll explore both the oven’s and bread machine’s advantages and disadvantages. So, we can answer this crunchy question and help you decide which is better for your needs. Find out if a bread maker or an oven works best for making gorgeous loaves of freshly baked bread!

Is a bread maker better than an oven?

Is a bread maker better than an oven?

Is a bread maker better than an oven?

A bread maker can be an incredibly useful and convenient tool with a diverse range of benefits. It is much easier to use than an oven, and it allows you to create delicious, warm bread at the touch of a button. See more at how does a bread maker work? for a better understanding about this machine.

A bread maker lets you set bespoke recipes and choose a loaf type. Hence, a bread maker may be better for beginner bakers or busy people who need fresh baked foods. In contrast, an oven may be better for those who want greater control over their baking.

Before choosing, examine both choices to find the best fit.

Clutter can be overwhelming

With a bread machine, the mess is no longer an issue when baking. All you have to do is toss all the ingredients in, and you’re done! No need for kneading either, which can be incredibly untidy—just add your components into the pan and let the machine do its job. Cleanup has also never been easier; with almost no clean-up required after baking, hassle-free baking awaits!

Baking bread in the oven is a notorious mess-maker, with ingredients mixing up in bowls and dough sprinkled on your counter. If you’re after an easier solution that doesn’t come at the expense of cleanliness, then a bread machine is perfect for you! No more washing up; it’s easy baking without added stress.

Kneading and proofing process

Kneading and proofing can be hassle-free with the help of a bread maker. Simply add the ingredients, press some buttons, and let it take care of everything else. There is no need to knead manually or keep an eye on the timer for perfect proofing.

Crafting your delicious homemade bread requires traditional baking techniques. Kneading the dough with your hands for 10 minutes (or however long is stated in the recipe) and proofing it at a precise temperature. By following these specific steps, you will be rewarded with an exquisite loaf that is truly worth savoring.

Seeking a swift and effortless way to knead your dough? A bread machine is just the device for you!

Timing and control

If you want convenience and speed, then a bread machine is the way to go. With a bread machine, you have a quick, non-supervised process to cook delicious loaves of bread quickly and efficiently, freeing up more time for other activities.

By contrast, baking bread in the oven isn’t quite as hands-off. Oven-baked loaves take more time to prepare, making it hard to multitask while making your masterpiece! Bread machines are designed to be a more convenient alternative to oven baking.

If you want to bake bread in the oven, you have to keep an eye on it the whole time it’s rising and baking. Additionally, you must take note of the temperature inside your oven so nothing gets burned. If speed is a priority for making fresh loaves at home, then investing in a quality bread machine could be an ideal solution for your needs!

Producing baked goods

Although a bread machine is convenient, it only bakes one loaf of bread at a time. If you want to make multiple loaves, unfortunately, you’ll need to wait until the first has been completed before beginning again.

Baking multiple loaves of bread at one time is a breeze when using an oven! With the right-sized model, you can make as many as you need – ideal for those who regularly bake in batches.

Remember that the mixer and oven can produce more than one loaf at a time. Bread machines are limited to one loaf per cycle.

As cited in

The loaf’s density

When making bread in a bread machine, the end product often has a denser and more compressed texture. This is due to not only the inadequate time for the dough to rise but also the fact that it’s confined within the limited space of the pan.

When it comes to oven bread, the texture is often more delicate than when utilizing a bread machine. Oven-baked loaves are typically lighter and fluffier due to having more space for rising and baking. It provides space for the bread to rise and spread without any interference. Consider using an oven for your next bake if you want a loaf of airy white bread!

Characteristics of bread and their crusts

Bread machines can’t alter crust thickness or form. Bread machines exclusively generate loaf-shaped bread. A bread maker cannot adjust crust thickness because it cannot preheat. A bread machine has no way to preheat itself. Once the machine has warmed up, the bread will begin to bake. Of course, this is fine if you don’t mind loaves of bread every week. For something more creative, you’ll need the oven.

Instead, use an oven. Bread can be shaped any way you like in an oven. To get varying crust thicknesses, preheat the oven. Want to produce bread in different forms and crust thicknesses? Get an oven.

Differ in function

When it comes to bread makers, there are a wide range of functions available. Higher-end machines have jam and dessert loaf cycles, sweet dough cycles, gluten-free cycles, and cake cycles. This makes them multipurpose kitchen gadgets.

Ovens can bake numerous loaves at once, but bread machines can’t.

Bread machine’s advantages and disadvantages

Bread machine's advantages and disadvantages

Bread machine’s advantages and disadvantages

The advantages

  • Convenience is without a doubt the key reason why people use bread machines. Simply pop in all of your ingredients, choose a cycle, and sit back while it does the work for you! Making fresh loaves with this appliance requires very little effort. Simply two to three hours—enough time to enjoy delicious homemade bread quickly and easily.
  • With a breadmaker, you can choose from an array of possibilities! Aside from the classic white loaf, you could also whip up whole wheat loaves, gluten-free options, and even pizza dough. Use all options to maximize your machine’s potential!
  • Anyone can become an expert baker without any prior knowledge by using a bread machine. With just the push of a button, you’ll be able to make fresh homemade bread in no time!

The disadvantages

  • One common issue with bread machines is that they leave an indentation, or hole, in the bottom of your loaves. This occurs because of the kneading paddle used to mix and knead the dough.
  • The cost: bread makers can be a bit pricey compared to other kitchen appliances. If you’re on a budget, this may not be the best option for you.
  • Noise: bread machines are quite noisy when in use. This can be a bit off-putting, especially if you’re trying to sleep or concentrate on something else.
  • Unconforming loaves: As this might be more of an issue for you than it is for me, a bread machine loaf may not always come out in the traditional square form. Instead, they often present themselves as somewhat rounded.
  • The bread’s texture: bread made in a bread machine may have a texture that some people find unsatisfactory. This might be fine for sandwiches, but it’s not ideal for toast or even French toast.

The advantages and disadvantages of baking bread in the oven

The advantages and disadvantages of baking bread in the oven

The advantages and disadvantages of baking bread in the oven

The advantages:

  • Many people prefer bread machine bread to oven-baked bread because they can make their own bread in the oven. This allows them to customize it exactly how they want, with an infinite number of possibilities!
  • When you make bread in the oven, you gain absolute authority over every step of the process.
  • The bread is unbelievably light and fluffy, offering a delightful texture.

The disadvantages:

  • Making bread in the oven can be a time-consuming process, requiring you to mix the ingredients, knead the dough, let it rise, shape it into loaves, and bake it.
  • Baking bread in an oven can be difficult and requires a certain level of skill. Baking bread in the oven requires specific temperatures and times, and if either one is off, you could end up with a loaf that’s too dry or undercooked.
  • An oven can be dangerous. The oven can get extremely hot and cause burns if you’re not careful. It’s important to take extra caution when handling it.
  • If you have an electric oven, baking bread on a regular basis will impact your energy bills.

FAQs Is a bread maker better than an oven?

Which breadmaker is the best?

Best Breadmakers

  • Best Overall: Cuisinart 2-Pound Bread Maker.
  • Best Overall (Splurge): Breville Custom Loaf Maker.
  • Best Budget: Amazon Basics 2-Pound Non-Stick Bread Making Machine.
  • Best Large-Capacity: West Bend Hi-Rise Bread Maker.

Should I bake bread in a Dutch oven?

For breadmaking, a good Dutch oven retains heat. Dutch ovens make it easy to capture steam for bread. Warm the pot, add the dough, and bake with the lid on for 15 minutes, then remove the lid.

What temperature should I use for making dough in a breadmaker?

How to use a breadmaker to make dough? Bake at 375° for 30–35 minutes, or until the loaf is golden brown and sounds hollow when tapped or reaches 200°. Allow to cool on racks.

What is the bake cycle of a bread machine?

Baking follows kneading, rising, and punching. Depending on the recipe, baking can take 40–70 minutes. The breadmaker bakes a crispy, tender loaf at 350 degrees Fahrenheit.


Ultimately, it’s up to the individual to determine which method best suits their needs. For those who want a quick, easy-to-use appliance to create small batches of homemade breads and pastries, a bread maker would be ideal. But for those desiring more control over baking results, taste preferences, and large quantities of food, an oven is better.

You should choose whichever is best or most convenient for you; both options are better than store-bought. At the end of the day, deciding whether a bread maker or an oven is “better” depends on your personal preferences and lifestyle choices. gives you no right or wrong answer.

Leave a Reply